Wash Times: Charter teachers file test complaint
- To: email@example.com
- Subject: Wash Times: Charter teachers file test complaint
- From: Marbleface@aol.com
- Date: Thu, 15 May 2003 10:23:09 EDT
- Cc: firstname.lastname@example.org
Charter teachers file test complaint
By Jabeen Bhatti
THE WASHINGTON TIMES
Teachers at the District's oldest charter school have filed a formal
complaint citing improprieties during standardized testing two weeks ago and
say the results should be invalidated. To
According to a May 13 letter to the D.C. Board of Education, at least
three teachers at Options Public Charter School in Capitol Hill were told by
Principal Clarence Dixon to "do some test prep" after receiving copies of the
Stanford 9 standardized test. The teachers had been waiting for a
school-system official to monitor the test, which was administered April 29
"Mr. Dixon said to me, ... 'Could you do some test prep or test material
on the board with the children?' " former Options teacher Sean Noriega said
in the letter. "Before I could tell him it was illegal, he left the room."
The Stanford 9 exam measures student achievement nationally in reading
and math and is administered to grades three through 11. According to testing
rules, teachers must stop test preparation once they have seen an exam,
In an interview with The Washington Times yesterday, Mr. Dixon denied
the accusations, saying the test was administered properly.
"We followed all the guidelines and procedures," he said, dismissing Mr.
Noriega's letter as "the view of a disgruntled employee."
But another teacher, who asked not to be identified, also said Mr. Dixon
had asked teachers to continue prepping students after they had received the
"It's true. We were waiting for the test monitors to get here after she
was late," the teacher told The Times. "Mr. Dixon asked me if I could
continue to do test prep, then proceeded to knock on other teachers' doors
and ask them the same thing. We are not allowed to do this."
Brenda Belton, who oversees charter schools for the D.C. school board,
said yesterday that she has received complaints about irregularities at
Options and intends to investigate, beginning this week with the school's
"We take these complaints seriously," Miss Belton said. "From my
knowledge, you cannot go back and do any kind of test prep once you have the
If the test results are invalidated, the school would be required to
retest its students. The test results do not affect student grades or school
In 2001, Montgomery County's school system disciplined several teachers
and administrators at Silver Spring International Middle School in Silver
Spring who had been involved in a cheating scandal in the administration of a
In his letter to the school board, Mr. Noriega also said one of his
Options students had told him the answers on her test had been changed after
she had submitted them.
"When I handed out my answer sheets on [April 30], a student, Ryan
Thomas, asked me who had changed her answer sheet," the letter reads. "When I
looked at her answer sheet, it was apparent that in two rows of answers,
someone had erased a large number of answers and changed them. Ryan said she
did not do this."
Robin Thomas, Ryan's mother, confirmed that the seventh-grader had told
her about the changed answers.
"[Ryan] came home one day after testing began and said it looked like
her sheet had been changed," Mrs. Thomas said. "I didn't think too much about
it at first, but she kept insisting on it."
Mr. Noriega was fired May 2 after he complained to Mr. Dixon about how
the Stanford 9 had been administered. The former teacher said he was not
given a reason for his termination.
School board officials said the termination resulted from Mr. Noriega's
tardiness and his leaving a class unattended. Mr. Noriega and several of his
former colleagues disputed those accusations.
Charles Vincent, executive director of Option's board of directors, said
he was unaware of the complaint against Mr. Dixon and had not been contacted
by school staff about the matter. He also said he was unaware that Mr.
Noriega had been fired.
"The safety of the kids has to come first," Mr. Vincent said. "A teacher
has to do his job."
In his interview with The Times, Mr. Dixon presented two reports by the
D.C. school-test monitor Carolyn Davis in which she noted no irregularities
other than a delay in testing due to a bomb threat April 28.
But several Options teachers said Mrs. Davis was not at the school when
Mr. Dixon directed them to continue prepping students for the test.
Bill Caritj, assistant D.C. schools superintendent for assessment and
accountability, said yesterday that nothing in the examiner's manual
addresses this issue.
"It doesn't say that just because you have the test in the room, you
can't give a five-minute practice drill," Mr. Caritj said. "Whether I think
it leaves open the perception that a teacher did something wrong is another
question. To be fair to the school, we have to have the facts."
Chartered in 1996, Options has 148 students in grades five to eight and
a staff of 23. It is one of 16 schools overseen by the D.C. school board.
Post a Message to arn-l: