[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Sowell / Thernstrom on racial gaps or lack of
- To: "Arn-L" <firstname.lastname@example.org>, "fair-diversity" <email@example.com>, "Wa-Ed" <firstname.lastname@example.org>, "educationloop" <EducationLoop@yahoogroups.com>
- Subject: Sowell / Thernstrom on racial gaps or lack of
- From: "Arthur Hu" <email@example.com>
- Date: Wed, 24 Sep 2003 18:02:41 -0700
- Importance: Normal
From: Americans Against Discrimination and Preferences
[mailto:AADAP-L@HOME.EASE.LSOFT.COM]On Behalf Of AADAP
Sent: Wednesday, September 24, 2003 1:25 PM
Subject: School performances
AADAP-L, a free, moderated email list with daily postings, is a project of
Americans Against Discrimination and Preferences (www.aadap.org).
Thomas E. Wood, President and Moderator
Thomas Sowell (archive)
September 24, 2003
Everyone knows that black students in general do not perform as well in
school as white students, much less Asian American students. But few realize
how painfully large the gap is. Even fewer know that there are particular
black schools, even in low-income neighborhoods, where students perform
above the national average.
Discussing racial gaps in education is taboo in some quarters. But this
subject is discussed deeply and thoroughly in a new book titled "No Excuses:
Closing the Racial Gap in Learning" by Abigail Thernstrom of the Manhattan
Institute and Stephan Thernstrom of Harvard. They are also the authors of
the best book on race relations -- "America in Black and White" -- so there
are high expectations for this new book.
"No Excuses" lives up to those expectations. If you read just one book about
American education all year, this should be the book. It not only goes into
the causes and cures of racial disparities in education, in the process it
punctures many of the fads, dogmas, and pious hypocrisies of the education
First, the existing gap: Black high school students graduate an average of
four years behind white students in academic skills. In other words, the
high school diplomas they receive are given -- not earned -- for a junior
high school education.
The excuses for this range across the spectrum from poverty to racism and
even innate lack of ability. Yet none of these excuses stands up to the
As the Thernstroms show, there are some schools where the students are
equally poor and equally black, where test scores are outstanding. Moreover,
such schools seldom get any more money than the schools that are failing.
Some of the most heavily financed schools are doing miserably. Even spending
$17,000 per pupil, Cambridge, Massachusetts was still left with a huge gap
between the test scores of its black and white students. In fact, black
students in Cambridge scored lower than other black students in nearby
communities with less than half as much spending per pupil.
Those who believe that money is the answer are not going to be stopped by
anything so mundane as facts. To many in politics and in the media -- and to
everyone in the teachers unions -- "improving" the schools means spending
more money on them. But what is called "investing" in better education could
more accurately be called pouring money down a bottomless pit.
Don't suburban schools with high levels of spending do better than other
schools with lower levels of spending? Usually, yes. But Olympic-sized
swimming pools and tennis courts do not make you any smarter. Nor do
generous-sized parking lots for affluent students with fancy cars.
"No Excuses" does not limit its comparisons to blacks and whites. In some
cases, the educational performances of Asian American students exceeds that
of whites by more than the performances of whites exceed that of blacks.
There is nothing mysterious about any of these differences. Asian students
put more time into study and homework and watch less television. They behave
themselves in class. Their parents don't tolerate low grades -- or even
In those rare black schools where the students follow a pattern similar to
that of Asian Americans, they get educational results similar to those of
What about the role of the schools in all this?
American schools waste an incredible amount of time on fads, fun and
propaganda for political correctness. Those students who come from homes
with highly educated parents, or parents whose values stress education, get
a lot of what they need outside of school, as well as making the most of
what they get within the school.
It is those children who do not come from these kinds of homes whose futures
are forfeited when class time is frittered away. Low-income black students
are the biggest losers when educators fail to educate and when courts create
so many legal obstacles to enforcing school discipline that a handful of
classroom clowns or hoodlums can prevent everyone else from getting a decent
More money won't cure any of this.
AADAP-L, a free, moderated email list with daily postings, is a project
of Americans Against Discrimination and Preferences (http://www.aadap.org).
You can subscribe, unsubscribe, or get information on AADAP-L by sending
electronic mail to LISTSERV@HOME.EASE.LSOFT.COM. In the message body (not
the header), type the
following commands (capitalized text only):
SUBSCRIBE AADAP-L [to subscribe]
SIGNOFF AADAP-L [to unsubscribe]
INFO AADAP-L [to receive more information on the list]
Please feel free to forward this to anyone you think might be interested.
Post a Message to arn-l: